Cheese

104 products

104 products

Quick view
Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz
$9.45
Quick view
The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz
$9.95
Quick view
Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese
from $5.75
Quick view
Baker String Cheese Singles
$1.00
Quick view
Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz
$4.00
Quick view
BelGioioso Fontina
$4.50
Quick view
Henning's Muenster
from $5.69
Quick view
Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz
$8.10
Quick view
Ellsworth Dill Pickle Cheddar Cheese Curds 5oz
$3.99
Quick view
Nordic Creamery Parmesan 8oz
$7.25
Sold Out
Gibbsville Pepper Jack Cheese 15.5oz
$6.73
Sold Out
Boar's Head Creamy Blue Cheese Crumbles 6oz
$5.95
Sold Out
Gibbsville Sharp Cheddar Rindless 15.5 oz
$6.42
Quick view
Carr Valley Glacier Penta Creme Blue 5 oz
$6.70
Quick view
Henning's 9 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar
from $11.75
Quick view
Cheese Counter Cheese Club
from $60.00
Quick view
Sargento Natural Sharp Cheddar-Jack 8oz
$3.90
Quick view
Sargento Creamery Mozzerella 6oz
$3.90
Quick view
Sargento Creamery Mild Cheddar 6oz
$3.90
Sold Out
Gibbsville Mild Cheddar 15.5 oz
$6.08
Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz

Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz

$9.45
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The intense, bold flavor characteristics of The Stag, with it's rugged, driving strong toffee and butterscotch notes yet it possesses a sweet finish. As it ages, The Stag develops a hint of crystalline crunch to further enliven the taste buds with rich texture as well as flavor. The Stag, a true Wisconsin Original.
The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz

The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz

$9.95
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This 1-pound tubs are a delightful dairy treat – we blended our 13-year Wicked White cheddar with some Grade A Wisconsin Cheddar to get the perfect balance of tangy, aged sharpness and creamy, spreadable goodness.
Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese

Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese

$5.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Aged over 90 days.
Baker String Cheese Singles

Baker String Cheese Singles

$1.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz

Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
BelGioioso Fontina

BelGioioso Fontina

$4.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Fontina develops an exceptional mild, buttery flavor, with a smooth, almost silky texture.
Henning's Muenster

Henning's Muenster

$5.84
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A semi soft cheese with a brick like texture.
Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz

Gibbsville Vegetable Rindless Cheese 15.5 oz

$8.10
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Natural Rindless Mild Cheddar Cheese with Vegetables.
Ellsworth Dill Pickle Cheddar Cheese Curds 5oz

Ellsworth Dill Pickle Cheddar Cheese Curds 5oz

$3.99
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Nordic Creamery Parmesan 8oz

Nordic Creamery Parmesan 8oz

$7.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This fresh Parmesan has all the taste characteristics of traditional aged Parmesan, with a very approachable milder flavor and an unexpected creaminess

Carr Valley Glacier Penta Creme Blue 5 oz

$6.70
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Henning's 9 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

$11.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Pairs well with Nuts, Apples, Dried Cherries, & Hearty Crackers
Cheese Counter Cheese Club
Cheese Counter Cheese Club
Cheese Counter Cheese Club
Cheese Counter Cheese Club

Cheese Counter Cheese Club

$60.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

The monthly cheese club is a great way to try a wide variety of cheeses and have them delivered to your door every month. 

Shipped out the first Monday of the month.  Approximately 2 lbs of a variety of Wisconsin cheeses each month.  

Sargento Natural Sharp Cheddar-Jack 8oz

Sargento Natural Sharp Cheddar-Jack 8oz

$3.90
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The rich, smooth taste of Monterey Jack is the perfect complement to the tangy zing of Sharp Cheddar in this always-popular blend of cheeses. Our Sharp Cheddar Jack is aged to perfection— with distinctive marbling to appeal to all your senses. Our new block cheese gives you the freedom to slice, grate, cube and use however you please
Sargento Creamery Mozzerella 6oz

Sargento Creamery Mozzerella 6oz

$3.90
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The simple addition of real cream gives Sargento® Creamery Mozzarella a delicious buttery flavor and smooth, creamy texture that’s irresistible. You’ll love the amazing melt and soft texture of this 100% real, natural cheese. Creamery Mozzarella makes hot sandwiches, appetizers, lasagna and pizza more melty and delicious than ever.
Sargento Creamery Mild Cheddar 6oz

Sargento Creamery Mild Cheddar 6oz

$3.90
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Creamery Mild Cheddar Cheese delivers an amazing melt thanks to the simple addition of real cream. You’ll love the buttery flavor and smooth texture. This 100% real, natural cheese has a pleasantly mild flavor that brings melty deliciousness to your favorite breakfast entrées and grilled cheese sandwiches.