Cheese

135 products

135 products

Quick view
Henning's Two Tone Curds
$6.50
Quick view
Cedar Valley String Cheese
$10.00
Quick view
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
$6.00
Quick view
Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds
$6.50
Quick view
Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds
$6.50
Quick view
Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar
$7.25
Quick view
Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread
$8.50
Quick view
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack
$7.00
Quick view
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Henning's Cajun Curds
$6.50
Quick view
Sartori Old World Cheddar
$6.00
Quick view
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
$6.00
Quick view
Dairy Fudge Cheese
$10.65
Quick view
Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar
$6.50
Quick view
The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar
$12.95
Quick view
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Deer Creek The Doe
$9.50
Quick view
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz
$9.95
Quick view
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
$8.50
Quick view
Meister Bruschetta Jack
$7.00
Quick view
Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar
$8.50
Quick view
Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges
$7.75
Quick view
Henning's Tequila Lime
from $4.27
Quick view
Henning's Blueberry Cobbler
from $4.58
Henning's Two Tone Curds
Henning's Two Tone Curds
Henning's Two Tone Curds
Henning's Two Tone Curds

Henning's Two Tone Curds

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A blend of white and colored cheddar cheese curds!
Cedar Valley String Cheese
Cedar Valley String Cheese
Cedar Valley String Cheese
Cedar Valley String Cheese

Cedar Valley String Cheese

$10.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Cedar Valley Cheese Store's factory fresh string cheese.
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar
Sartori MontAmore Cheddar

Sartori MontAmore Cheddar

$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Is it Cheddar that tastes like Parmesan or Parmesan that tastes like Cheddar? Even though it's indescribable, we know you'll fall in love with this creamy, white wonder.
Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds
Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds
Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds
Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds

Henning's Traditional Cheddar Curds

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Bite size pieces of fresh Cheddar cheese. *A Wisconsin favorite.*
Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds
Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds
Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds
Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds

Henning's Garlic & Dill Curds

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Fresh, young, white cheddar cheese with garlic & dill

 

Recipe ideas: Appetizers, snacking, poutine, kabobs, and salads. 

Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar

Masters Gallery 5-Year Aged Cheddar

$7.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
One of our most popular cheeses. This 5 year aged Cheddar is wildly popular because of it's taste, texture, and versatility.
Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread
Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread
Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread
Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread

Masters Gallery Red Ale Cheddar Spread

$8.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Wisconsin Extra Sharp Cheddar is revved up with Elkhart Lake's own Switch Gear Brewery's craft-brewed Resorter Red Ale for a new spin on classic Bear Cheese.
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
By wedding this rich, creamy cheese to the berry and plum notes of Merlot, we've created a marriage of flavors destined to make your taste buds say, "I do." On that note, if you invite a few friends from our pairing guide - say, toasted walnuts, thin slices of prosciutto and semisweet chocolates for dessert - the honeymoon never has to end.
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge

Sartori Black Pepper BellaVitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The fruit of the black pepper vine, used since antiquity in European cuisine, is present here again to accent our finest creation - rich, nutty, creamy BellaVitano®. By adding just the right pinch of cracked black peppercorns, we impart a spicy zestiness that's nothing to sneeze at. To the beautiful life!
Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack
Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack
Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack
Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack

Meister Wild Morel and Leek Jack

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Semi-soft Monterey Jack is blended with wild, earthy morel mushrooms and delicately flavored leeks. This creamy, uniquely flavored cheese is a real crowd pleaser, pairs well with light wines and is the original Morel & Leek Jack ever produced!
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge

Sartori Tennessee Whiskey BellaVitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Full of spirit and a smooth sweetness, Tennessee Whiskey meets the rich, creamy BellaVitano in this new classic cheese. Breathe in that clear country air and savor the sweet life
Henning's Cajun Curds

Henning's Cajun Curds

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Cheddar cheese curds blended with Cajun seasoning.
Sartori Old World Cheddar
Sartori Old World Cheddar
Sartori Old World Cheddar
Sartori Old World Cheddar
Sartori Old World Cheddar
Sartori Old World Cheddar

Sartori Old World Cheddar

$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Old World Cheddar delivers an incredible flavor that profiles sweet, savoy notes and finishes with a buttery touch. Delightfully sharp notes highlight and brighten this robust, full of flavor white cheddar.
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar
Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar

Sartori Farmhouse Cheddar

$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Inspired by our dedicated local family farms, Farmhouse delivers a perfect combination of sharp, savory, and buttery notes in an experience that is extra rich and full of flavors. 
Dairy Fudge Cheese
Dairy Fudge Cheese
Dairy Fudge Cheese
Dairy Fudge Cheese

Dairy Fudge Cheese

$10.65
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar
Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar

Masters Gallery 2-Year Aged Cheddar

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Master's Gallery 2 year Cheddar is the perfect combination of smooth and creamy with the classic sharp Cheddar taste. 10.5 oz
The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar
The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar
The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar
The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar

The Big Cheese 13 Year Cheddar

$12.95
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
For those who want to savor a devilishly smooth cheddar with a salty edge that will leave you wanting more, try this 13-year aged cheddar.
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge

Sartori Raspberry Ale BellaVitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This is our own nutty, creamy, award-winning creation - soaked with handcrafted Raspberry Tart ale. The bright notes of ruby-red raspberries combine with hazelnut and brown-butter flavors to make a deliciously complex cheese. "The beautiful life" never tasted so good.
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe
Deer Creek The Doe

Deer Creek The Doe

$9.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The Doe is a gracefully creamy handcrafted bandaged-wrapped Cheddar marbled with intoxicatingly aromatic pure Madagascar Bourbon vanilla bean. This special cheese begins with wholesome rBST-free milk from Wisconsin. During the cheese-making process, we add freshly ground whole vanilla bean and then age the cheese to allow the flavors to mellow and penetrate throughout. The result is a uniquely perfumed velvety Cheddar that is savory with a sweetly woody finish.
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge
Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge

Sartori Gold BellaVitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A Sartori-family original, this rich, creamy cheese with its nutty, fruity flavor is also - in all modesty - a celebrated gold-medal winner. Inspired by traditional, Italian farmstead cheese, BellaVitano® Gold begins in the mouth like a premium Parmesan and finishes in award-winning style with hints of melted butter. This is where our artisan cheesemaking first began to shine.
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge
Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge

Sartori Rosemary & Olive Oil Asiago Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Rosemary provides the perfect savory high note for this rich, nutty and fruity taste sensation. A gold-medal winner of the World Championship Cheese Contest, this extraordinary delight wears its laurels as lightly as the perfect balance of hand-rubbed rosemary and Italian olive oil.
The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz

The Big Cheese Aged Cheddar Cheese Spread 16oz

$9.95
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This 1-pound tubs are a delightful dairy treat – we blended our 13-year Wicked White cheddar with some Grade A Wisconsin Cheddar to get the perfect balance of tangy, aged sharpness and creamy, spreadable goodness.
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake
Deer Creek The Rattlesnake

Deer Creek The Rattlesnake

$8.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

The Rattlesnake is a true flavor experience — spicy, sweet, tropical, and HOT. We start with a smooth, creamy medium aged Cheddar and infuse it with premium gold tequila and Habanero peppers. The warmth and sweetness of the tequila open your palate to the smooth and creamy mellowness of a perfectly aged Cheddar. And just when you are wondering where the Habaneros are, the heat bursts forth for an unforgettable finish. Watch out — this cheese just might bite you back!

 

7 oz

Meister Bruschetta Jack
Meister Bruschetta Jack
Meister Bruschetta Jack
Meister Bruschetta Jack

Meister Bruschetta Jack

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A semi-soft Monterey Jack with mild flavors of tomato, garlic, parsley, and basil. A real crowd pleaser at all gatherings.
Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar
Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar
Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar
Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar

Wood River Creamery Black Truffle Cheddar

$8.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A unique Cheddar Gruyere cheese accented with real Italian Black Truffles making this an aromatic and flavorful cheese.
Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges
Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges
Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges
Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges

Deer Creek Blue Jay 5.3oz wedges

$7.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Made using a recipe in which five ten-gallon cans of cream are added to each vat, The Blue Jay is rich in texture with strong buttery notes. We then crush juniper berries to release their perfume and infuse them throughout to complement the Blue strain’s unique botanical essence. The result is a bold, yet utterly creamy Blue with a delicately piney bouquet that blooms in your mouth. 
Henning's Tequila Lime
Henning's Tequila Lime
Henning's Tequila Lime
Henning's Tequila Lime

Henning's Tequila Lime

$4.92
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Tequila & Citrus Lime

Recipe ideas: Scones, muffins, fish or shrimp tacos

Henning's Blueberry Cobbler
Henning's Blueberry Cobbler
Henning's Blueberry Cobbler
Henning's Blueberry Cobbler

Henning's Blueberry Cobbler

$4.83
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Sweet Blueberry & Cobbler

 

Recipe ideas: Pancakes, scones, muffins, and sweet grilled cheese.