Open!

11am - 4pm

mac & cheese, soups, grilled cheeses and panini sandwiches served from 10am - 3pm. Call today for carry out or Dine in.

FREE shipping on orders of $60 or more!!!

Employment Opportunity

Cheese Counter Guest Ambassador
Join Today

Cheese Counter Monthly Cheese Club

Monthly Deliveries of Wisconsin Cheeses and Snacks

SHOP OUR GIFT BASKETS

CHEESE CAPITAL FAVORITES GIFT BOX

Creamy, sharp, peppery, sweet and savory – just plain good. The flavors you’ll experience in this special box are uniquely crafted in the Cheese Capital of the World. We’ve packed a variety of palate-pleasing cheeses to upscale your holiday party, beer or wine pairing or (c’mon, get real) personal stash

ORDER NOW

WORLD CHAMPION CHEESE BOX

The best in one box. This selection of six world championship-winning cheeses will make the perfect gift, holiday party platter or special ingredient in a meal for loved ones. See how a taste of Wisconsin – celebrated globally – will make the season memorable.

ORDER NOW

Wisconsin Cheddars Gift Box

Wisconsin's Finest Cheddars in one Gift Box.  Bold, Sharp, Creamy, and Tangy! The BIG CHEESE 13 Year Cheddar, Henning's 7 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar, Master's Gallery 5 Year Cheddar, Sartori's Old World White Cheddar, and Gibbsville's Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Order Now

Cheese: It’s on the Menu. Now Online!

order now

Shop Historical Downtown

Our location in downtown Plymouth, the Cheese Capital of the World, is a destination for visitors and locals alike. Stop in to browse our fine selection of award-winning, locally produced cheeses, discover great gift ideas and immerse yourself in cheesemaking history.

shop now
Wisconsin Cheddars Gift Box
Wisconsin Cheddars Gift Box
Regular price $55.00
/

Only 11 items in stock!
Wisconsin's Finest Cheddars in one Gift Box.  Bold, Sharp, Creamy, and Tangy! The BIG CHEESE 13 Year Cheddar, Henning's 7 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar, Master's Gallery 5 Year Cheddar, Sartori's Old World White Cheddar, and Gibbsville's Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese.   Includes plain box for in house pick up. Shipping extra.

SHOP BY CATEGORY

GIFT BOXES

SHOP NOW

LUNCH COUNTER MENU

SHOP NOW

PANINI'S

SHOP NOW