Cheese

115 products

115 products

Quick view
Henning's Aged Brick Cheese
from $7.54
Quick view
Pine River Port Wine 8 oz
$4.00
Quick view
Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Henning's Mango Fire
from $4.34
Quick view
Henning's Bacon Fest
from $4.36
Quick view
Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Henning's Garlic & Dill
from $3.36
Quick view
Henning's Onion & Chive
from $3.28
Quick view
Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar
from $4.27
Quick view
Wood River Creamery Herbes De Provence
$6.50
Quick view
Sartori Parmesan Shredded
$5.00
Quick view
Meister Dill Havarti 6oz
$7.00
Quick view
Henning's Mozza Whips 10oz
$6.50
Quick view
Adam's Reserve New York Aged Cheddar 16 oz
$7.25
Quick view
Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese
from $4.00
Quick view
Henning's Limburger
$8.79
Quick view
Wood River Creamery Chipolte Garlic Cheddar 8 oz
$6.50
Quick view
Henning's 7 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar
from $7.51
Quick view
Nordic Creamery Grumpy Goat 8 oz
$10.50
Quick view
Meister Mediterranean Cheddar 8oz
$7.00
Quick view
Henning's Cranberry Orange Cheddar
from $0.00
Quick view
Henning's Tomato Basil
from $3.56
Quick view
Carr Valley Boozin' Ewe
$9.00
Quick view
Carr Valley Goat Gouda 5oz.
$9.00
Quick view
Nordic Creamery Goat Muenster 8oz
$9.25
Quick view
Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz
$7.00
Quick view
Pine River Garden Vegetable 7 oz
$4.00
Quick view
Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz
$10.00
Henning's Aged Brick Cheese

Henning's Aged Brick Cheese

$9.92
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

This brick is cured with a special smear making it tangy and pungent. If you keep the foil on, it will continue to age.

 

Surface Ripened, Pungent, & Tangy

 

Pairs well with rye bread, beef, and hearty crackers.

Pine River Port Wine 8 oz

Pine River Port Wine 8 oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge
Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge
Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge
Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge

Sartori SarVecchhio Parmesan Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Ask a pear or walnut which cheese they prefer and they’ll say, “One that’s fruity, with hints of lightly roasted caramel, aged to crumbly perfection.” In other words, our finest Parmesan. Which, in all modesty, is also America’s most highly decorated Parmesan, thanks to the skill of our cheesemakers and the good taste of judges around the world.
Henning's Mango Fire

Henning's Mango Fire

$4.92
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Sweet Mango & Habanero

 

Recipe ideas: Corn dip, tacos, nachos, and chicken. 

Henning's Bacon Fest
Henning's Bacon Fest
Henning's Bacon Fest
Henning's Bacon Fest
Henning's Bacon Fest
Henning's Bacon Fest

Henning's Bacon Fest

$5.20
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Smoked Bacon, Onions, & Dill Pickles

 

Recipe ideas: Omelettes, potato salad, burgers, and cherry dips.

Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge
Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge
Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge
Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge

Sartori Classic Asiago Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This is a wonderfully mild and versatile grana-style cheese, justly famous for its nutty flavor, pungent aroma and creamy finish. You'll find it enhances just about everything from soup to nuts - including pizza, pasta, salads and flatbreads. Along with the judges at the 2009 World Cheese Awards, we say "Ahhh-siago" every chance we get.
Henning's Garlic & Dill

Henning's Garlic & Dill

$4.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Savory Garlic & Dill

 

Recipe ideas: Eggs, mashed potatoes, veggie salads, and burgers. 

Henning's Onion & Chive

Henning's Onion & Chive

$3.89
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
White Cheddar blended with onion and chives. 
Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar
Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar
Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar
Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar

Henning's Simply Strawberry Cheddar

$5.02
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Refreshingly Delicious Strawberries

 

Recipe ideas: Dip in chocolate, fruit skewers, and crepes. 

Wood River Creamery Herbes De Provence

Wood River Creamery Herbes De Provence

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Our unique Cheddar Gruyere cheese enriched with the savory mixture of aromatic Mediterranean herbs.
Sartori Parmesan Shredded

Sartori Parmesan Shredded

$5.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
We're quietly grateful for the sweet, mellow, nutty flavor of this perfectly mature Sartori favorite. Because Parmesan accompanies so many foods so graciously, we offer ours in every form you could ask for. This way, "Will you please pass the Parmesan?" can always be answered in the affirmative.
Meister Dill Havarti 6oz

Meister Dill Havarti 6oz

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A semi-soft Havarti with a fresh dill taste. A creamy texture with a mild buttery flavor.
Henning's Mozza Whips 10oz

Henning's Mozza Whips 10oz

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Small thin pieces of string cheese. A low moisture, part skim mozzarella cheese snack. Makes a great party appetizer. - 10oz bag
Adam's Reserve New York Aged Cheddar 16 oz

Adam's Reserve New York Aged Cheddar 16 oz

$7.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese
Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese
Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese
Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese

Henning's Baby Swiss Cheese

$4.60
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Aged 60 days or less.

 

Mild, Buttery, & Slightly Sweet

 

Recipe ideas: Ham & cheese balls, fondue, and grilled cheese.

Henning's Limburger

Henning's Limburger

$8.79
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Surface Ripened, Earthy, & Pungent

 

Pair with rye bread, pretzels, and strawberry jam. 

Wood River Creamery Chipolte Garlic Cheddar 8 oz

Wood River Creamery Chipolte Garlic Cheddar 8 oz

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Our unique Cheddar Gruyere cheese combined with a blend of chipotle chili peppers and roasted garlic.
Henning's 7 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Henning's 7 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

$9.12
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Aged over 7 years

 

Pair With Nuts, Apples, Dried Cherries, & Hearty Crackers

Nordic Creamery Grumpy Goat 8 oz

Nordic Creamery Grumpy Goat 8 oz

$10.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Grumpy Goat is an award-winning, bold, semi-hard, but still creamy, goat cheese, cellar-aged over 1 year for an audacious robust flavor.
Meister Mediterranean Cheddar 8oz

Meister Mediterranean Cheddar 8oz

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A semi-hard Cheddar with sun-dried tomatoes, kalamata olives, oregano and basil. Top a pizza for a new twist!
Henning's Cranberry Orange Cheddar

Henning's Cranberry Orange Cheddar

$4.89
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Sweet Cranberres & Citrus Orange

 

Recipe ideas: Scones, chicken salad, pancakes, and fruit salad.

Henning's Tomato Basil

Henning's Tomato Basil

$3.56
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Sun-Dried Tomato & Basil

 

Recipe ideas: Lasagna, pasta salads, chicken & Italian dishes.

Carr Valley Boozin' Ewe

Carr Valley Boozin' Ewe

$9.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Award-winning sheep milk cheese, Marisa, is soaked in local Wollersheim Winery Port for a beautiful purple rind and sweet flavor.
Carr Valley Goat Gouda 5oz.

Carr Valley Goat Gouda 5oz.

$9.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Nordic Creamery Goat Muenster 8oz

Nordic Creamery Goat Muenster 8oz

$9.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz
Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz
Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz
Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz

Meister Medium Cheddar 8oz

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Semi-hard/hard cheddar that is aged over 60 days to develop a rich, creamy, smooth flavor.
Pine River Garden Vegetable 7 oz

Pine River Garden Vegetable 7 oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz

Deer Creek The Stag 5.3oz

$10.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The intense, bold flavor characteristics of The Stag, with it's rugged, driving strong toffee and butterscotch notes yet it possesses a sweet finish. As it ages, The Stag develops a hint of crystalline crunch to further enliven the taste buds with rich texture as well as flavor. The Stag, a true Wisconsin Original.