Cheese

115 products

115 products

Quick view
Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz
$8.50
Quick view
Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar 5oz
$6.00
Quick view
Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge
$6.25
Quick view
Meister Garlic Pesto Jack 6oz
$7.00
Quick view
Meister Monterey Jack 8oz
$7.00
Quick view
Pine River Garlic & Herb 8 oz
$4.00
Quick view
Pine River Swiss & Almond 7 oz
$4.00
Quick view
Henning's White Cheddar Curds 10oz
$6.50
Quick view
Henning's Caraway Cheddar Cheese
from $3.63
Quick view
Hoard's Dairyman Belaire 6oz
$10.00
Quick view
Decatur Dairy Settler Colby Swiss Spread 8oz
$6.00
Quick view
Henning's 9 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar
from $9.45
Quick view
Roth Spinach Artichoke Gouda
$5.85
Quick view
The Big Cheese Herb and Garlic Spread 16oz
$9.95
Quick view
Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz
$4.00
Quick view
Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese
from $5.50
Quick view
Pine River Aged Asiago 7oz
$4.00
Quick view
Gibbsville Colby 15.5oz
$7.25
Quick view
The Big Cheese Port Wine Spread 16oz
$9.95
Quick view
Gibbsville One Pound Muenster
$8.25
Quick view
Carr Valley Glacier Penta Creme Blue 5 oz
$6.75
Quick view
BelGioioso Fontina
from $4.75
Quick view
Marieke Overjarige Aged Gouda 2 years+ 8oz
$12.75
Quick view
Hook's Triple Play
$11.75
Quick view
Henning's Blazing Buffalo cheddar
from $4.27
Quick view
Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz
$8.75
Quick view
Henning's Mild Cheddar
from $4.65
Quick view
Widmer Butterkase 8oz
$8.50
Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz
Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz

Gibbsville Super Sharp Rindless 15.5 oz

$8.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar 5oz

Sartori Cherrywood Smoked Cheddar 5oz

$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
MontAmoré® Cheddar is naturally smoked, to bring out the fruity & sweet notes. The aromatic Cherrywood smoke fills your mouth right away with a subtle, sweet-smoke flavor.
Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge
Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge
Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge
Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge

Sartori Chardonnay Bellavitano Wedge

$6.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Meister Garlic Pesto Jack 6oz

Meister Garlic Pesto Jack 6oz

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This semi-soft cheese with the perfect balance of garlic and basil is great on your favorite cracker or topping a pizza.
Meister Monterey Jack 8oz

Meister Monterey Jack 8oz

$7.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This semi-soft, natural cheese is mild and pleasantly flavorful with a smooth creamy texture.
Pine River Garlic & Herb 8 oz

Pine River Garlic & Herb 8 oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Pine River Swiss & Almond 7 oz

Pine River Swiss & Almond 7 oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Henning's White Cheddar Curds 10oz

Henning's White Cheddar Curds 10oz

$6.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Henning's Caraway Cheddar Cheese

Henning's Caraway Cheddar Cheese

$4.34
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Warm & Savory Seeds

 

Recipe ideas: Breads, potatoes, brisket, and pulled pork.

Hoard's Dairyman Belaire 6oz

Hoard's Dairyman Belaire 6oz

$10.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Our Belaire, Port Salut-style variety is an exquisite, mild, and classic cheese that’s easy to eat and will quickly become one of your favorites. Its creamy, subtle flavor and soft texture make it an ideal cheese for formal occasions or a Sunday afternoon on the patio. 
Decatur Dairy Settler Colby Swiss Spread 8oz

Decatur Dairy Settler Colby Swiss Spread 8oz

$6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Decatur’s creamy lace style Stettler Swiss blended with Decatur’s Colby into a cheese spread.
Henning's 9 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

Henning's 9 Year Extra Sharp Cheddar

$10.91
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Aged over 9 years

 

Pair With Nuts, Apples, Dried Cherries, & Hearty Crackers

Roth Spinach Artichoke Gouda

Roth Spinach Artichoke Gouda

$5.85
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
This new classic pairing has all the flavors of your favorite dip in creamy Roth Gouda.
The Big Cheese Herb and Garlic Spread 16oz

The Big Cheese Herb and Garlic Spread 16oz

$9.95
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz

Pine River Chunky Bleu Spread 7oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese

Henning's Regular Swiss Cheese

$6.04
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Aged over 90 days.

 

Buttery, Nutty, & Full Flavored

 

Recipe ideas: Fondue, potatoes, turkey or ham sandwiches.

Pine River Aged Asiago 7oz

Pine River Aged Asiago 7oz

$4.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Gibbsville Colby 15.5oz

Gibbsville Colby 15.5oz

$7.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The Big Cheese Port Wine Spread 16oz

The Big Cheese Port Wine Spread 16oz

$9.95
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Gibbsville One Pound Muenster

Gibbsville One Pound Muenster

$8.25
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Carr Valley Glacier Penta Creme Blue 5 oz

Carr Valley Glacier Penta Creme Blue 5 oz

$6.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
BelGioioso Fontina

BelGioioso Fontina

$4.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Fontina develops an exceptional mild, buttery flavor, with a smooth, almost silky texture.
Marieke Overjarige Aged Gouda 2 years+ 8oz

Marieke Overjarige Aged Gouda 2 years+ 8oz

$12.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
 With undertones of spice, coffee, caramel, and roasted nuts this true farmstead Gouda is anything but plain. All Marieke® Gouda is made using fresh raw milk from our family farm. They handcraft each wheel with the finest Old World techniques and age the Gouda to perfection on Dutch Pine Planks.
Hook's Triple Play
Hook's Triple Play
Hook's Triple Play
Hook's Triple Play

Hook's Triple Play

$11.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Milky, tangy, and a bit sweet, this triple milk (cow, goat, and sheep) cheese has three starters (Gouda, Baby Swiss, and Havarti). It is a great all-around cheese that is a crowd pleaser
Henning's Blazing Buffalo cheddar

Henning's Blazing Buffalo cheddar

$4.27
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Spicy Peppers & Zesty Heat

 

Recipe ideas: Nachos, enchiladas, burgers, and chicken.

Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz
Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz
Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz
Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz

Deer Creek The Fawn 5.3oz

$8.75
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
A unique culture set gives this young cheese an award-winning sweet nuttiness with a full, complex Cheddar flavor not found in traditional bandage-wrapped Cheddars. As the flavor of The Fawn unfolds in your mouth, it seems delicate at first, yet gives you a rich finish that lingers on.
Henning's Mild Cheddar

Henning's Mild Cheddar

$5.30
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Widmer Butterkase 8oz

Widmer Butterkase 8oz

$8.50
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
If you’re looking for a truly versatile cheese that’s a refreshing alternative from the mainstream, we’ve got a suggestion for you. It’s mild enough that kids will love it (and it makes a killer mac and cheese), yet sophisticated enough to serve with fine wines at a grownup gathering. Intrigued? We thought so. Meet Butterkäse.